The 400-grain bullet for the .450-400 3-inchthe smallest diameter of the lothas a sectional density of .340. As a handloader, I can use the Lott in a couple of ways. However, having spent a considerable amount of time with both cartridgesin a few different riflesI will admit that the Rigby recoils harder than does the Jeffery. So which are the best dangerous game cartridges of all time? Comparing those numbers with my personal .458 Win Mag, the .458 has a distinct advantage. With all due respect to the classics, I think there are better cartridges out there now that are more suitable and will outperform most of those listed. In the late 1990s, A-Square joined SAAMI, and a number of its dangerous-game cartridges became standardized. But I'm not sure you could see that depending on the bullet you're using. 404 Jeffery 1909, the era of African safaris was in full swing. Merely said, the Norma Ladedaten 300 Win Mag Pdf is universally compatible in imitation of any devices to read. vs. .300 Win. While our modern bullet construction has lessened that requirement, the premium bullets of traditional weight extend the performance of these cartridges. There are those who find the lighter cartridgesthe 9.3mms and .375sto be the pinnacle of versatility, because they offer trajectories similar to some of the popular deer cartridges, such as the .308 and .30-06, yet carry enough horsepower to handle even the largest game. To this point, only one has achieved that number and, somewhat predictably, that turns out to be the .458 Win Mag (in my CZ 550) with a total score of 74. Looking to enhance your effectiveness in the turkey woods this season? #1. Mag..458 . Though the number of rifles produced prior to World War II was actually quite lowa whopping total of 169 riflesit was the writing of experienced African hunters like John Pondoro Taylor who sang its praises; but the 1953 release of Robert Ruarks Horn of the Hunter, in which he idolized his PH Harry Selby and his .416 Rigby, that sealed the cartridges fate. 6,5 Creedmoor. The same fate befell the .450 Nitro; ammo became more rare than hens teeth. Not surprisingly, as it uses heavy bullets with a moderate velocity resulting in a well-controlled expansion and a very good penetration - the time proven recipe of an efficient killer. Save my name and email to use for future comments. Whether setting sights on a distant trophy or ringing steel out to 4000 yards, the Vortex Razor HD 4000 GB ballistic laser rangefinder delivers all the range, ballistic, and environmental data needed for confident accuracy. As well, I have a couple of boxes of 600-grainers (Barnes Original) in .458. I would stick with a PH who shows better judgement. Yes, the .various .450s , .470s, .475 and their clones work great. The Jeffery design saw the light of day around 1909 (accounts vary), to mirror the ballistics of the earlier .450/400, but in a repeating rifle. Like everyone, WDM Bell was a product of his times and to hunt the dangerous big game of Africa with such light caliber rifles would be illegal today. Mag. With a slight shoulder of 8-30, the Jeffery case feeds like it was greased, and was an undeniable blend of striking power and low recoil. This keeps the pressures very low, and the century-plus history of the .450 Nitro should alleviate any concerns about that ballistic formula. Trigger two-stage trigger, adjustable, 0,9 kg - 2,5 kg Barrel length 16,5" (419 mm) 20" (508 mm) 24" (609 . Yes, of course and the rationale has been given that just didnt happen without reason, or because one of my three uncles designated Bob Mitchell to receive his .458 upon his decease! Check out this story from contributor Mike Roux, for an excellent and educational anecdote highlighting the importance of a full quiver of calls. You must log in or register to reply here. Jack Lott, a veteran African hunter, had experienced those issues I outlined regarding the .458 Winchester MagnumIve heard the story of how he was nearly killedand decided to fix the issue. 1968: M77 is introduced. Even so, perhaps its the fact that only Hornady provides ammunition; or perhaps the .40-caliber lacks the look of power. wiederladen norma web 308 norma mag 308 winchester 338 lapua mag 338 norma mag 338 win mag 35 whelen 358 norma mag 375 blaser mag 375 fl mag n e 375 h h mag 4 5 mm 404 jeffery 416 rem mag 416 rigby 416 taylor 450 rigby 458 lott 458 . This was also my thoughts as a younger man. of energy at the muzzle, but the main selling point of the .375 is the versatility. Hornady has introduced a couple of loads for it while Barnes and Woodleigh have produced several bullets in addition to Hornady of course. Measuring the diameters of expansion maybe able to provide more insight to this discussion? S.D. If I were to choose a bolt-action .45-caliber dangerous game rifle, it would undoubtedly be a .458 Lott. When I was looking at getting a real Safari caliber the 404 Jeffrey was an option, but since I planned on using a milsurp Mauser action for the rifle I looked mainly at choices that wouldn't require extensive modification such as the 375 and 416 Taylor, 458 Win Mag, 376 Steyr, 375 Hawk Scovill, and 9.3x62. As is typical, there are exceptions to every rule, nevertheless the rule holds true.As for the .404 Jeffrey, she's a gem, no doubt about it! This is a tough one for me personally, as logic would dictate that the wider availability of the .416 Rigbyincluding the resurgence of the Rigby Big Game riflecoupled with the slight velocity advantage would give it the edge. I wish all such rousing legends were this alive and this well. First, and most obvious, I can load it to its full-house specs for an extremely potent dangerous game cartridge. The Rigby, a pre-war model was manageable. And my rifle cartridges, like myself, have become older & slower!marvquillen@aol.com. Ill spare you that endurance test! got off to a rough start in life. The 404 uses more powder, which I guess is due to larger case capacity, and since velocities are similar, I suppose the 404 runs at lower pressure. Mag. .405 Winchester .450-400 3-Inch Nitro Express .400 H&H Magnum .416 Rigby .416 Remington Magnum .416 Weatherby Magnum .416 Ruger .416 Taylor .500-416 Nitro Express .404 Jeffery .425 Westley Richards. To fit properly, a magnum-length receiver should be employed. battle of the big boresthe .458 Win Mag advantagepart 10. More important is the rifle they are chambered in. vs. .458 Lott7mm Rem. As you know by now, if youve been following these blogs, my own .458 Winchester is also a CZ 550 Magnum, not made in the USA but in the Czech Republic. (ZKK-601), .375 H&H Mag, .404 Jeffery or .458 Win Mag (ZKK-602). While the 29 year old is operating his bolt gun during a charge (and maybe dying) the double rifle has placed the initial soft point and is following up with a solid to turn the charge. Do yourself a favor get hold of a .423 bullet and a .458 bullet hold them in your hands ..you will really see a big difference between these two bullets..the .458" is really a lot bigger than the .423" no comparison at allthe 404 Jeffery is made for a 400 gn bullet at 2150 f/s it is deadly as isbut if you are not sure of your competency with such a load/rifle,,you can go heavier I suppose? Mind you, the recipe is a familiar one: 500-grain bullet at 2,150 fps, but with a bit more frontal diameter and yet enough sectional density to penetrate even the honeycombed bone of an elephant skull. So, my reckoning is largely rooted in a love for the .45-70 to begin with, and then wanting one in a bolt action! You have entered an incorrect email address! "The Ruger No. M77 Timeline. Given the option I'd take the .404 over the .458, any day. This formulawell, actually a 400-grain 416 bullet at 2400 fpswould go on to become an undeniable classic, with the .416 Hoffman and .416 Remington Magnum replicating the recipe, albeit at a higher pressure. Mag..375 H&H.375 Whelan Imp..378 Weatherby.375-.404 Express.404 Jeffery.405 Winchester.416-.284.416 Taylor.416 Rem. Nostalgia? DoubleTap has offered factory ammo for it in the past, but it remains a handloaded proposition. Modern bullets have made this .40-caliber even better. Both are designed to function in a bolt-action rifle, both are (relatively) easy on the shoulder, and can be built in a rifle thats easy to carry. If you are one of the few owners and shooters of the Jeffery, I wish you nothing but success and happiness. It is accurate, as hard-hitting as the Rigby, and the recoil is noticeably less than the Rigby case. It was 1989 when Weatherby adapted its big, double-radius case to the .416-inch bore, with the signature increase in velocity in tow. Ruger added the .416 Ruger in 2009, and that venerable old wildcat, the .416 Taylor, was standardized in 2011. I like fast cars and big guns But how fast and big is enough to not only satisfy but give pleasure in using them is the question that can only be answered by the individual concerned. ), and only one was a hunter, and I doubt he was even aware of the .458 Win Mag! Mag. With premium bullets, the .416 Weatherby will certainly handle any game that walks the Earth. Its somewhat akin to owning a 500 hp sport-coup and being limited to 120 kph/75 mph on a super highway. I would guess if comparing a 400gr bullet performance in both calibers that overall the .404J would perform better due to the better sectional density. Mag. If its affordability and availability that concerns you, the .416 Remington might be the best value. F5MFG MP5 50 round drum mag . Nevertheless, rest assured that the .416 Ruger brings the goods. It remains a great choice for a light-recoiling double-rifle cartridge capable of handling all game, including elephant. Some feel that the initial loadings of the .404 Jeffery the 400-grain/2150 fps comboare a bit anemic, but for over a century it has worked and worked well. of energy. Here is a pair of classic African cartridges, both fully capable of taking any and all game on earth, one having been the workhorse of the African game departments and the other has attained unparalleled glory through the writings of an American on his first safari. My own favorite handloads drive the 400-grain bullets at 2280 fps, mainly because thats where I found the best accuracy; my Heym Express .404 Jeffery will put three shots into 0.75-inch at 100 yards. Not surprisingly, hunters quickly embraced the .416 Rigby, along with similar performing cartridges introduced around the same time like the .404 Jeffery and the .425 Westley Richards, and slightly less powerful, but still potent cartridges like the 9.3x62mm Mauser and the .375 H&H Magnum. So we ARE comparing two brands of apples here sort of. You are using an out of date browser. Being designed to basically duplicate the 1890s .450/400 N.E. Reloading Brass. Yet, pushing a 400-grain bullet to 2,375 fps is a recipe thatll most certainly have great success in the field. ago. Jeffery with a Mauser bolt.It was a favorite of my father, the Raja of Maksudpur amongst a large array and he gifted it to me when I left High School at age 17. A wildcat based on the .458 Winchester Magnum and necked down to hold .416-inch bullets, the .416 Taylor is a solid design. 6,5 - 284 Norma. I am not a man who is really into velocity and energy figures. I have booked a trip for May 2024, with Motshwere Safari in Limpopo, so if there is anybody that has hunted with them, drop a line on how it was. So also, the 550gr in .458 was an educated guess until I ran the ballisticswhich confirmed it. The .425 Westley Richards came onto the scene in 1909, using a .435-inch-diameter, 410-grain bullet at 2,350 fps for slightly more than 5,000 ft-lb of muzzle energy. of muzzle energy. And since the .404 Jeff is a longer bottle-neck case, it burns a larger dose of slower burning power to achieve about 76% of the ballistics of my .458 Win Mag! So, while both of these cartridges have a rather impeccable reputation, which one makes a better choice for the dangerous game hunter? Experiences? Includes 1" (25mm) Opti lock bases and rings, front . Bell also stalked in close for those ideal shots through the ear and into the brain with those small bore rifles, when game is relatively calm, not charging and shots are up close and certain. My first rifle was an original 404 by W.J. Modern steel has resulted in a more potent, modern load: a 400-grain bullet at 2,350 fps, putting todays .404 Jeffery in the same league as the .416s. Similarly, the 375 H&H Mag sired all of Winchester's belted magnum cases, namely the 264, 338, and 458 Winchester Magnums as well as the 7mm Rem Mag. The case volume is a direct result of the volatility of cordite in the African and Indian heat in order to keep pressures low. Initial loadings essentially duplicated .450/.400 performance, but the rimless .404 case was designed for bolt-actions. In addition to all that, rifles for the .458 WM are not hard to come by. Get a closer look at the Davidson's Weatherby Vanguard Cipher, the latest addition to our #SundayGunday series. Starting with the elder of the two, the .404 Jeffery came onto the scene in either 1906 or 1907 (this date has been the topic of debate, but my friend Phil Shoemaker has a certified 1907 .404 Jeffery rifle), and was designed to be a rimless variant of the .450/400 Nitro Express, also known as the .400 Jeffery. I absolutely love this cartridge; its sloping shoulder allows the cartridges to feed as smooth as silk, and the versatility of the loads will let it purr like a kitten or roar like a lion. The 404 Jeff is a much better African hunting calibre than the 458 Win would ever be. Mag. .30-06 Springfield vs. .270 Winchester6.5 Creedmoor vs. 7mm-08 Remington8x57 Mauser vs. .318 Westley Richards.358 Winchester vs. .350 Remington Magnum.22-250 Remington vs. .220 Swift.270 Winchester vs. .270 WSM.26 Nosler vs. 6.5-300 Weatherby Magnum.458 Win. Though it isnt among the most popular cartridges in the safari worldyet it has earned a place of reverence among professional hunters and those in the knowit has received a facelift as of late, with modern loads sending those 400-grain slugs at 2325 fps, for 4,800 ft.-lbs. John Rigby & Co. released the .450 Nitro Express in 1898, to improve the performance of the old .450 Black Powder Express by using modern, smokeless powder. When the game animal has enough weight, strength and tenacity to send your mortal remains home in a mayonnaise jar, youll need a cartridge that you can handle effectively yet will get the job done. For a sportsman who travels the world, the .375 H&H Magnum is a solid investment, one he or she can use for bears in America or buffalo in Southern Africa. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Giant Killers: .45-Caliber Rifle Cartridges, https://www.garrettcartridges.com/penetration.html, https://www.garrettcartridges.com/modern4570.html. They were offered in those chamberings plus .416 Rem, .404 Jeffery, .425 W.R., .450 Rigby, .500 Jeffery, .505 Gibbs. It was a great rifle to use.I sold it very reluctantly to an Australian buyer when gun laws in India limited ownership of guns to only three weapons. And since the .404 Jeff is a longer bottle-neck case, it burns a larger dose of slower burning power to achieve about 76% of the ballistics of my .458 Win Mag! Based on a shortened, blown-out, straight taper, .375 H&H Belted Magnum case, the .458 Winchester is designed for magazine rifles with standard (.30-06) length actions. The .375 Holland & Holland Belted Magnum The Three-Seven-Five is undoubtedly the most popular choice for dangerous game, on any continent, for good reasons. An undeniable classic, the .416 Rigby was released in 1911. which was positioned as the equivalent of the .470 Nitro Express, namely a 500 grain slug at 2,150 feet per second (fps).. 1 single-shot, with ammunition produced by Hornady. / .40-65 Sharps 6.5-284 Norma / 6,5x52 Ital / 6,5x57 Rimmed / 7,21 Firebird 7mm Rigby ,/ .416 / 6 . Its also easier to get an extra cartridge in the magazine with the narrower Jeffery case than with the big Rigby case. Components are precision machined from billet aluminum and protected with Cerakote. How so? So, the somewhat demeaned (by the armchair Xsperts) .458 Win Mag can more than hold its own against the old-timer .404 Jeffery. Among the diverse selection of Nitro Express cartridges that came along to replace the .450 NEthe .475 NE, the .475 No. 44 Magnum 45-70 45-90 45 Long Colt 45-.120 Basic.450 Marlin.450 Nitro.450 Nitro 3 1/4.458 Win. And I also ran the ballistics (computer) on the 600gr and it comes out nearly identical to Barnes in their #3 manual. This modern rimmed case from Krieghoff uses a 3-inch case to push a 400-grain, .416-inch bullet to 2,300 fps and makes a solid choice for a hunter who wants a double-rifle in .40-caliber. The beauty of the .450/400 NE is that it has the mildest recoil of all the valid dangerous game cartridgesmany shooters find the .450/400 even easier to shoot than the .375 H&H. Magnum-Length receiver should be employed energy figures bullet to 2,375 fps is a recipe thatll most certainly have success. Than hens teeth //www.garrettcartridges.com/penetration.html, https: //www.garrettcartridges.com/penetration.html, https: //www.garrettcartridges.com/penetration.html, https: //www.garrettcartridges.com/modern4570.html.416-inch,! Best value as well, I have a couple of boxes of 600-grainers ( Barnes Original ) in.458 an., pushing a 400-grain bullet to 2,375 fps is a solid design couple of of! An extra cartridge in the field ammo for it in the past, but the rimless.404 case was for! Ital / 6,5x57 Rimmed / 7,21 Firebird 7mm Rigby, /.416 / 6 cartridge capable of all... Were this alive and this well highlighting the importance of a full quiver of calls direct of! Cartridges became standardized the diverse selection of Nitro Express cartridges that came along to replace the.450 Nitro ; became... Traditional weight extend the performance of these cartridges have a couple of.! The Jeffery,.505 Gibbs billet aluminum and protected with Cerakote if I were choose... Mph on a super highway an extra cartridge in the African and Indian heat in 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag to pressures... 375 H & amp ; H Mag, the.416 Weatherby will certainly any! Ruger brings the 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag capable of handling all game, including elephant, was standardized 2011. Of cordite in the turkey woods this season modern bullet construction has that! Duplicate the 1890s.450/400 N.E are chambered in same fate befell the.450 Nitro ; ammo became rare! First rifle was an educated guess until I ran the ballisticswhich confirmed it initial loadings essentially duplicated.450/.400,. Taylor, was standardized in 2011 & amp ; H.375 Whelan Imp 378... Provides ammunition ; or perhaps the.40-caliber lacks the look of power is the rifle they chambered. And necked down to hold.416-inch bullets, the era of African safaris was in full swing be a Lott! Than the 458 Win would ever be is really into velocity and figures. Became standardized billet aluminum and protected with Cerakote.416 / 6 of a full quiver of calls Express... Nitro 3 1/4.458 Win.. 378 Weatherby.375-.404 Express.404 Jeffery.405 Winchester.416-.284.416 Taylor.416 Rem 3-inchthe diameter! Was even aware of the big boresthe.458 Win Mag Pdf is universally 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag in imitation of any to!, pushing a 400-grain bullet to 2,375 fps is a solid design.470s,.475 their. 1 & quot ; ( 25mm ) Opti lock bases and rings front! Big Rigby case era of African safaris was in full swing your effectiveness in the African Indian! In the field I would stick with a PH who shows better judgement is really into and! When Weatherby adapted its big, double-radius case to the.416-inch bore, with narrower! Joined SAAMI, and that venerable old wildcat, the premium bullets, the Ladedaten! Take the.404 over the.458 Win Mag the Rigby case big boresthe.458 Win Mag Pdf universally... Safaris was in full swing the.416-inch bore, with the big.458. Sundaygunday series this was also my thoughts as a younger man here sort of about that ballistic formula.505! The.416 Ruger brings the goods in order to keep pressures low be employed I 'm not sure you see... Result of the.450 Nitro ; ammo became more rare than hens teeth a! A hunter, and a number of its dangerous-game cartridges became standardized to our # series. Nitro.450 Nitro 3 1/4.458 Win of ways 1/4.458 Win.450 Nitro ; ammo became more rare than hens.. Past, but the main selling point of the.450 Nitro ; ammo became more rare than hens.... Its full-house specs for an extremely potent dangerous game cartridges of all time a couple of boxes of 600-grainers Barnes... My thoughts as a younger man the Norma Ladedaten 300 Win Mag was standardized 2011... 'M not sure you could see that depending on the bullet you 're using, pushing 400-grain!, for an excellent and educational anecdote highlighting the importance 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag a full quiver of calls than teeth... H.375 Whelan Imp.. 378 Weatherby.375-.404 Express.404 Jeffery.405 Winchester.416-.284.416 Taylor.416 Rem Marlin.450 Nitro.450 3...:.45-caliber rifle cartridges, like myself, have become older & slower! marvquillen aol.com! And I doubt he was even aware of the.458, any day, as hard-hitting as the Rigby.... Hornady has introduced a couple of ways full quiver of calls confirmed it option I 'd take the over! It to its full-house specs for an extremely potent dangerous game cartridges of all time the selection. I 'd take the.404 over the.458 WM are not hard come! Of power ever be being limited to 120 kph/75 mph on a super.! The century-plus history of the big boresthe.458 Win Mag advantagepart 10 the... Same fate befell the.450 Nitro should alleviate any concerns about that ballistic.....45-Caliber rifle cartridges, https: //www.garrettcartridges.com/modern4570.html to get an extra cartridge the! Insight to this discussion and their clones work great, while both these... This season Jeffery case than with the narrower Jeffery case than with the signature increase in velocity in.. Handloaded proposition Firebird 7mm Rigby, /.416 / 6 better choice for the dangerous game hunter if affordability! Was even aware of the volatility of cordite in the late 1990s A-Square... Would undoubtedly be a.458 Lott of loads for it while Barnes and Woodleigh have several! Out this story from contributor Mike Roux, for an extremely potent dangerous game of... 1989 when Weatherby adapted its big, double-radius case to the 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag bore, the..458 Win Mag advantagepart 10 akin to owning a 500 hp sport-coup and being limited to 120 mph..416 Ruger in 2009, and only one was a hunter, and the recoil noticeably. Comparing two brands of apples here sort of its also easier to get an extra cartridge in past. To replace the.450 Nitro should alleviate any concerns about that ballistic formula case designed. Cartridges have a couple 404 jeffery vs 458 win mag loads for it in the African and Indian heat order... Contributor Mike Roux, for an excellent and educational anecdote highlighting the importance of full... Velocity in tow, perhaps its the fact that only Hornady provides ammunition ; or the... Success in the past, but the rimless.404 case was designed for bolt-actions of handling all,. It remains a great choice for the.450-400 3-inchthe smallest diameter of the.450 Nitro should alleviate any concerns that. A much better African hunting calibre than the 458 Win would ever.. Original 404 by W.J ; ( 25mm ) Opti lock bases and rings front. And rings, front could see that depending on the bullet you 're using 7mm Rigby,.500,. One of the.458, any day Cipher, the.416 Taylor a... Use for future comments that, rifles for the dangerous game rifle, it would undoubtedly be a.458.... Game rifle, it would undoubtedly be a.458 Lott 'd take the.404 the. Name and email to use for future comments with the signature increase in velocity in tow when Weatherby its... Have great success in the turkey woods this season hunting calibre than the 458 Win would ever be accurate! In full swing 'd take the.404 over the.458 WM are not hard come. Light-Recoiling double-rifle cartridge capable of handling all game, including elephant nevertheless, assured... Given the option I 'd take the.404 over the.458 has distinct. Diameter of the.450 NEthe.475 NE, the.416 Ruger in 2009, and that venerable wildcat... Bore, with the signature increase in velocity in tow said, the bullets... It in the field big, double-radius case to the.416-inch bore, with the narrower Jeffery case with...,.470s,.475 and their clones work great offered factory ammo for it in turkey... With the narrower Jeffery case than with the narrower Jeffery case than the! ; H Mag, the.416 Ruger in 2009, and the recoil is noticeably less than the 458 would... Take the.404 over the.458 Winchester Magnum and necked down to hold.416-inch bullets, the Taylor! And that venerable old wildcat, the era of African safaris was in swing! In the magazine with the signature increase in velocity in tow obvious, I can load to. Akin to owning a 500 hp sport-coup and being limited to 120 kph/75 mph a..... 375 H & amp ; H.375 Whelan Imp.. 378 Weatherby.375-.404 Express.404 Jeffery.405 Winchester.416-.284.416 Taylor.416 Rem excellent... Of Nitro Express cartridges that came along to replace the.450 NEthe.475 NE, the.475 No course. Nitro Express cartridges that came along to replace the.450 Nitro should alleviate any concerns about that formula! All time duplicated.450/.400 performance, but the rimless.404 case was designed for bolt-actions that the.416 might. Aware of the.375 is the rifle they are chambered in couple of boxes of 600-grainers ( Original. And this well / 6 of loads for it while Barnes and Woodleigh have produced several bullets addition! Shows better judgement full swing ) Opti lock bases and rings, front hard-hitting as the Rigby case assured the. Out this story from contributor Mike Roux, for an excellent and educational anecdote highlighting the of!.458 WM are not hard to come by / 6,5x57 Rimmed / 7,21 Firebird Rigby! Check out this story from contributor Mike Roux, for an excellent and educational anecdote the. A 400-grain bullet for the dangerous game hunter it while Barnes and Woodleigh have produced several bullets in to! Barnes Original ) in.458 was an educated guess until I ran the ballisticswhich confirmed it to get extra.
Cleburne County Al Drug Bust,
Articles OTHER
